Why so productive? Why so many big fish? A favorable combination of climate, underlying geology

Why so productive? Why so many big fish? A favorable combination of climate, underlying geology, and tailwater conditions is the common understanding.

Here’s an article from the Friday edition of the Idaho Statesman:

South Fork has big trout, but fewer small ones

Biologists, anglers study rainbow populations to figure out what’s going on.

BY ROGER PHILLIPS – rphillips@idahostatesman.com

Edition Date: 05/09/08

Big fish, good, but fewer fish, bad. That’s what’s happening on the South Fork of the Boise River, and state and federal biologists and local fly fishing clubs are trying to find out why.

For more than 20 years, the Idaho Department of Fish and Game has tracked trout populations on the South Fork between Anderson Ranch Dam and Danskin Bridge, which is one of the most popular trout fishing areas in Southwest Idaho.

Population surveys show a downward trend in wild rainbow trout in the 5- to 9-inch range, fewer fish in the 10- to 16-inch range, but more fish larger than 16 inches.

F&G, Trout Unlimited, the Forest Service, Boise Valley Fly Fishermen, and the Bureau of Reclamation are partnering on projects to learn more about the South Fork’s trout population, what might be affecting it and how they can protect and enhance it.

There will be a full overview of the projects at 6:30 p.m. Wednesday, May 14, at the MK Nature Center at 600 Walnut St. in Boise.

The river still has a healthy trout population, many of which are wild, native rainbows and bull trout.

But F&G has found there are more larger trout than could be produced by the numbers of smaller trout in the system.

Radio telemetry studies showed bull trout migrate in and out of the South Fork, which raises the question of whether large rainbow trout are produced in the South Fork or are born elsewhere and migrate there.

It also raises questions why there are fewer small fish in that section of the South Fork and whether it has adequate spawning and rearing habitat.

Mike Toalson, board member for the Ted Trueblood chapter of Trout Unlimited, said all parties want to get more information before deciding what to do.

“It wouldn’t behoove us to take remediation actions until we know what’s going on,” Toalson said.

Projects include a redd count to discover how many fish are spawning in that section of the river, which will be done this month.

In June, biologists and volunteers will survey South Fork tributaries between Anderson Ranch Dam and Arrowrock Reservoir to see how trout are using them.

In July, there will be a large project that will include sport anglers catching trout and biologists taking samples for genetic testing to try to determine whether the South Fork’s trout were born there, or migrating from someplace else.

In late summer, F&G and volunteers will descend into the South Fork’s “canyon” section below Danskin Bridge to survey trout populations and see how they compare with upstream sections.

To learn more about projects on the South Fork of the Boise River, log onto www.southforkboise.org

Graphic from late 1970s showing movement of tagged fish in the South Fork Boise

Graphic from late 1970s showing movement of tagged fish in the South Fork Boise.  Some indications of fish movement out of the South Fork.  Did those fish start in the South Fork and move out, or did they come from somewhere else and visit the South Fork only to leave?  The upcoming genetic study may shed some light on this topic.

Our website masthead

Time to Volunteer

It’s time to pitch in and help out this river we all love.  We’ve launched an effort involving local angler groups and agencies (F&G, Boise NF, BuRec) to look into improving the SFB fishery. The first step is to understand what happens in this fishery since the trout have access downstream to Arrowrock Reservoir and thus the Middle Fork, North Fork and beyond. Migration of trout and Bull trout has already been documented.

We have an immediate need for volunteers for some of the following planned projects:

Tributary Flow Surveys
No recent data exists to support potential enhancement of tributaries to make them more accessible for spawners. We have a method to monitor flow rates but need volunteers to go by the river to take some quick, easy measurments from April 30 to mid-June. See some recent pictures of tributaries below.

Main Stem & Tributary Redd Survey
A Boise NF biologist did a thorough redd count in the main river from the dam to Danskin in 2007 and plans to repeat that next month. We have added counting redds in the tributaries for sometime around 5/31 and could use some strong volunteers.

Genetic Study and Fish Sampling Day – July 12
The center piece of the 2008 conservation research will be a genetic study to understand the origins of the fish that make up the South Fork fishery. The local TU chapter received an Embrace-a-Stream grant to underwrite part of the cost of this project. We are also looking for contributions to sponsor fish and sponsors will get a report back on that fish’s genetic history. We will sample fish (non-lethally) from the South Fork Boise below Anderson Dam, and the tissue samples will be used to profile the local rainbow trout population and compare it to an existing library of genetic profiles for wild rainbow trout populations throughout the headwaters of the North, Middle and South Fork of the Boise River. With this data, the biologists can determine where the resident fish originate and then we can determine if spawning enhancements in those location could help the fishery.

The sampling event will be on July 12. We need volunteers to FISH in the name of science or provide driftboats, cooking and shuttles for the weekend event. This looks to be a family event so all are welcome. We can include an informal competition as part of the event as well – should be a really fun day.

Tagged ,

Genetic study outline

The centerpiece of the 2008 conservation research will be a genetic study to understand the origins of the fish the make up the South Fork fishery. We will sample fish from the South Fork Boise below Anderson Dam, and the (non-lethal) tissue samples will be used to profile the local rainbow trout population and compare it to an existing library of genetic profiles for wild rainbow trout populations throughout the headwaters of the North, Middle and South Fork of the Boise River.

Continue Reading…

Tagged